16 Feb

NetBalancer: should you trust it?

Last few months people kept bashing antivirus and security software in general. Like on Twitter or their personal pages. Sure, Twitter is full of opinionated idiots who just love to complain about everything that doesn't match their point of view. On a few occasions they are right and even I have written about some of the issues with antiviruses before.

But!

But you'd be f*king stupid to delete your antivirus just because it has some bugs. Doorlocks get picked by criminals every day and people still use them. Professional lockpickers do exist - it's their job to break lock's security mechanism and get you back in the house when you lose your keys. Tavis Ormandy is a professional lockpicker - only he works in the digital world. It's his job to break digital security mechanisms and help vendors to fix the issues.

Having said that, not all software is created equal. Sometimes new and dangerous features get added to an otherwise great software. These features look good on paper but they can really ruin someone's day. Today, I'll demonstrate one such feature.

Introducing SeriousBit NetBalancer

NetBalancer is a Windows application for local network traffic control and monitoring. It shows you the network traffic on your computer and helps you to set limits, priorities and rules for that traffic. Some sort of a firewall - but better. It can prioritize your traffic, schedule it for specific times, do statistics, make graphs and charts and what not. And it looks really good!

Predefined Priorities

NetBalancer's Predefined Priorities is a feature that looks great on paper.

For those of you who are not sure what priorities are best for your PC we decided in NetBalancer 8.5 to add some predefined priorities.
These priorities include the most used programs and processes, currently about 1700 total (and counting), and are set to match the needs of most users

It could be used for virtually everything:

  • giving high priority to VoIP applications and games
  • making sure background processes (eg. software updaters) don't interrupt your Youtube experience
  • and even blocking malware

The possibilities are endless. In fact, virtually all of the antivirus products use similar databases to preconfigure their firewalls. It makes total sense after all!

However, the devil is in the details. All such databases must be maintained. New version of Skype comes out, you need to update database. League of Legends releases new update, you must update the database. And you must do it very fast, so that your users don't suffer from misbehaved firewall. It's a lot of work.

Since NetBalancer is made by a small company called SeriousBit SRL, I was naturally curious how they manage to do that. smile

Inside Predefined Priorities

First, I needed to obtain the complete database of the priorities. You could try to find something in C:\ProgramData\SeriousBit\NetBalancer\ but it would be more interesting to find and download correct files for the official servers, right? smile After a quick string search, I learned that priorities can be downloaded from https://netbalancer.com/api/internal/predefinedpriorities. It's a huge JSON file but isn't encrypted or signed in any way.

That's a serious red flag right there. Security companies vigorously protect their databases - it's their know-how, their crown jewels. And they use digital signatures to make sure that the databases aren't tampered with. After all, which developer wants to see his product in news like "MalwareBytes: multiple security issues"? smile

OK, in this case JSON file is downloaded over HTTPS, therefore it's slightly harder to intercept traffic and modify it. So, let's ignore this issue for a moment and look at the JSON data instead.

In a minute or two, I was in the full "WTF?" mode.

Here's an excerpt from the JSON, prettified for easier viewing:

Setting high priority for RAR and TMP files.. More than 2000 entries like that? WTF?

How about this?

Yes, I want to download my porn with a high priority, thank you very much!

But how on earth that got through the QA process? Is there any QA process in SeriousBit SRL? I highly doubt that..

Unsolicited user data gathering

All those entries made me think - how is it possible that NetBalancer's database contains such crap information? Most obvious answer was - it's submitted by users. To verify the guess, I took a sneak peek inside SeriousBit.NetBalancer.Core.dll. And there it was:

The call is coming from here:

There you have it - if you have enabled "Predefined Priorities", NetBalancer will also silently upload all your priorities to their servers.

Want to wreak some havoc with unsuspecting users of NetBalancer? Post your own JSON file that blocks all traffic for all the browsers - apparently NetBalancer doesn't validate user submissions and will happily distribute them to other users. bigsmile

Abusing existing database

I was also wondering what is the meaning of ExeNameCrc field. smile Turns out that NetBalancer uses CRC32 of filename as a key in the dictionary that manages process priorities To make matters easier, they also supply you with a proper filename in ExecutablePath field. So, if you want to make sure your malware has unlimited traffic and high download priority, just name it swarm.exe:

Indeed, CRC32("swarm.exe") = 1475648703, as you can verify in some online CRC32 calculator..

A quick test confirms that too:

Conclusion

Trust is a delicate subject. On the one hand, all the Cloud and Connected things make your life much easier. On the other hand, you must choose wisely who you trust and what data he/she can access. I doubt that SeriousBit intentionally created such buggy and dangerous feature in NetBalancer. But that doesn't mean I would ever want it to be running on my machine!

Have fun and stay safe!